“You're such a dork. To me, this is a compliment.
[Insert a few cracks about how he thought he found someone cute and witty then discovered _______ embarrassing thing about me. Something for which I will have to “make up” for with future awesomeness] He made me laugh immediately. His sarcasm was spot on and his humor was intelligent.
You seem pretty chill and down to Earth; however I do have some important questions:
1) If you could have any super power what would it be and why? Great question! Especially because I had just seen XMen First Class. I was uber-prepared to answer.
You seem pretty chill and down to Earth; however I do have some important questions:
1) If you could have any super power what would it be and why? Great question! Especially because I had just seen XMen First Class. I was uber-prepared to answer.
2) Most adventurous thing you've done as of late? (and no running with scissors doesn't count) Fuck! I’m not that “adventurous” by normal standards.
3) Favorite bar or wine bar in [Our city]? Recently I went to this little wine bar off [Insert Street Name] called [Insert Bar Name]. It was pretty legit. Second great question! He opened up the opportunity to invite me on a date if things go well.
[Insert a P.S. bringing attention to a band I like and simultaneously teasing me about a funny photo I posted of myself in relation to said band] His postscript also made me chuckle. He made a connection through music and then took a fair punch at me.”
[Insert a P.S. bringing attention to a band I like and simultaneously teasing me about a funny photo I posted of myself in relation to said band] His postscript also made me chuckle. He made a connection through music and then took a fair punch at me.”
Rattail’s message stood out for the following reasons: He made me laugh out loud (and at myself), he had clearly spent time reading my profile, he kept me interested for the entire message, the message itself was not too lengthy, and he gave me information about himself without sending a biography, which I could have read on his profile. I have a pet peeve when guys will message saying hello followed by “A little bit about me………… [Insert their entire “About Me” paragraph from their profile.] I can easily go read someone’s page to learn more about them, but it’s important that you show me you took the time to learn something about ME.
I have to admit, out of all of the guys I have met, talked to, been on dates with, etc Rattail’s sense of humor mirrored mine in such a perfect way that I was nearly intimidated by him. When I tell you Rattail is really funny, I am not telling you that I am really funny, I’m simply implying it.
All jokes aside, I was very interested in getting to know this guy.
It took a week of clever messages back and forth for Rattail to finally ask if I was “emotionally available” for texting. It took THREE WEEKS after the first text to finally have our first date. Remember when I said it’s important to meet someone pretty quickly so that you don’t get too attached to the version of them that you’ve created through texting, emails, and all that jazz? I cannot express to you how firmly I believe in this theory. I have to admit that I put off meeting Rattail on two occasions. I was in a vulnerable place for a few months, and I was really enjoying the attention I got texting with him. We were somehow becoming friends and making inside jokes before we had even met. He requested me as a friend on Facebook to make sure I wasn’t “the Octomom or into weird things or something… In a good way.” Every single thing he said to me made me smile, and I was nervous to meet him. His subtle cockiness was so well displayed that I even found myself jealous of girls on his Facebook whom he had recently friended. Clearly, he had friended these cute girls with the same features as me to make sure they, too, were not the Octomom. At this point, I realized I am bat shit crazy – certifiably nuts. Who thinks these things? I had somehow put him on a pedestal when I had no reason to even care about any of these people. I DO NOT KNOW THIS HUMAN. All I knew was he was a dorky insurance underwriter who got his “Check Please” nickname after telling me he was going to get a rattail at his haircut the day before our first date – asking if it would change my mind about showing up.
I realize that all of this information makes me seem pathetic, slightly stalker-ish, and insecure, but if you can honestly say you wouldn’t overthink some of these things than more power to you. I promised myself to be honest to my readers under the assumption that my audience would not judge me, but instead keep reading. You know deep down, we share a little bit of crazy. I’m just here to admit it. It’s amazing how social networking can affect real life, without having any tangible contact to it whatsoever. Here I found myself vulnerable to someone I had never met. Two days before my date with Rattail, I went on a third date with Brooklyn and decided to stop worrying about what might or might not come of any of these adventures. Take THAT Rattail. You don’t scare me. I had bigger issues to worry about. Was Brooklyn going to kiss me that night? Oh god. This was going to ruin everything.
Luckily, I was distracted enough by Brooklyn to not cancel my bowling date with Rattail. My brothers had given me a bowling ball and purple bowling shoes for my birthday, and Rattail suggested we put them to good use. To my surprise, Rattail was tall, handsome and just the perfect amount of geek. It makes my heart warm to hug someone you’ve been waiting to meet. You can feel each other’s anticipation beating rapidly behind your chest. He was just as nervous as I was, and I smiled to myself. Somehow, his fear helped calm me down and we talked for about an hour at the bar before setting up to bowl. “The Dude” must have been looking down on me with a glimmer in his eye because somehow I bowled two strikes in a row on the first game. Talk about impressive. I love to bowl, but I will admit that bowling as a first date was awkward.
![]() |
| "The Dude" |
Wanna know why?
First of all, you have to come up with a funny Bowler Player Name. You are not cool if you pick your own name, and you do not know your competitor well enough to make one up for them. We couldn’t use our dating site usernames. That would just feel strange. So, I made Rattail’s RATTAIL and mine, THE DUDE for obvious reasons.
Next there is the uncomfortable “Choosing of the Balls,” which I had taken care of by owning my own great red ball of fire. I felt guilty watching Rattail roam around the alley picking up random hot pink, lime green and orange bowling balls - bouncing them each up and down a few times to get a feel for the weight, the finger holes, and overall comfort of all the options. I was relieved that I had the perfect ball. It matched my fingers, it was just the right weight and it had a personality that rolled with mine. If only I could find a man that fit me as well as my beloved ball.
I do not know if putting on bowling shoes is uncomfortable for other people, but now that I have my own, I think I have become a bit of a snob. Other than immediately knowing your date’s shoe size, there is a sanitary concern with public shoe usage. Without thinking, I scrunched my nose and said “Do you know how many people have put their feet in those things?” Luckily Rattail is quick witted and snapped back with “Do you know you’re wearing bowling shoes the color of Barney?” I proudly said “YES!” We giggled and started our game.
The most awkward part about bowling on a first date is the minutes in between your bowling turn. Every single turn is the same story. You stand there egging on your opponent as they uncomfortably bend over to show you their rear end. They stand there looking away from you as their ball hopelessly heads towards the pins. Then they either turn around with a celebratory ARMS UP IN THE AIR BECAUSE THEY DID WELL or a disappointed shoulder shrug for their gutter ball. Now… you stand up and welcome them back to home base with a high five and snarky “Nice try!” You take your turn showing off what your mama gave you. Then you try to act as cool as possible by holding your hands over the stupid hand drier praying it will help what is about to happen in your lane. You bowl your second shot and head back to your chair. The same jokes are made, the amount of time spent actually talking to eachother is zero, and this continues for at least one hour.
After Rattail won the second and third games, we both were ready to retire. He asked me if we could go somewhere to hang out a little longer. I was feeling sleepy, but I had not spent enough time with my date to decide if I would want to see him again. So… we went to a bar and stayed there for three hours goofing around. Rattail is weird and awkward like me. He has a higher pitched, nerdy voice, and is not embarrassed to ask me anything. At one point, he dared me to question some old men who had walked into the bar how old they were. We nicknamed one of them Santa. Confronting these men was a terrible idea. All of a sudden I was surrounded by sleezy (but harmless) old geezers flirting with me. I was trying so hard to keep a serious face while Rattail sat at our bar stools laughing at me. I quickly ditched the gray hairs and went back to my date. When we finally decided to leave the bar, Rattail put his arm around me and walked me to my car. He gave me a quick peck and asked if I would save him a date after I got back from my vacation in two weeks.
So here I was driving back from a seemingly perfect date and all I could think about was Brooklyn. Rattail really was a great guy. He is so funny and I can see myself hanging out with him. But there was just no “chemistry.” I told myself I would go on my vacation and see how I felt when I came back.
However, the last thing I was expecting on my vacation was to hear from Dr. Snotface. Like a wave crashing down over me, I lost all control and replied shortly after I got back home. In my lifetime, no man has ever chased me down as much as this jerk and it felt amazing. I knew he was no good, but it was so easy to talk to him. He apologized for things he’d done. I yelled at him for things he’d done. And then we just started catching up and laughing about stuff. I did not see him to post that previous blog post from his couch until a month and a half later. Yes. I was at his house. I am sure you are shaking your head at me. This was the “unfortunate” time period when Brooklyn dropped off the face of the planet, but I will get into ALL of this after I tell you about Brooklyn’s and my third date.
There it is. I lied. London had not yet asked me out for ice cream when I posted that blog. That didn't happen until a week later…………..……
- “Check Please!”

